Tonight’s Questions and Answers featured a heated exchange between Fintan O’Toole and Martin Cullen about whether the government knew how the pension levy was going to work when it was introduced. O’Toole has framed this question as being about whether the levy was applied to gross income or to net income. In his original article about this, he had asked
Is the levy a percentage of a worker’s entire income, or of that income after tax and PRSI? The answer to this question is crucial.
The article went on to heavily criticise the Taoiseach for asserting that the levy was applied to gross income and argued that this is not the case, a criticism that was repeated on Q&A.
Let me attempt to cut through the Gordian knot here and explain why both O’Toole and the Taoiseach are sure they are correct.